Turn Ideas Into InsightsWrite like a pro, even if you're not. AI magic at your fingertips.

(Un)True Crime: When they get the wrong guy

Feb 01, 2023 · 2 mins read

0

Share

In journalism, reporters can get it wrong sometimes. But the corrections and retractions go on the back page where no one reads. Law can operate in the same way. In a society obsessed with true crime, we often don't hear when it turns out we got it all wrong. Here's four cases:

Save

Share

The Central Park Five: In 1989, five Black and Latino teenagers were convicted of raping a white woman in New York City's Central Park based on forced 'confessions.' They served between 6 and 13 years in prison before DNA evidence cleared them in 2002. The five were awarded $41M.

Save

Share

Matias Reyes was later found to be the real culprit. He was a serial rapist and convicted murderer whose DNA was a match in the case. He also later confessed to the Central Park case. The mini-series When They See Us was made about the original conviction of the teens.

Save

Share

Steven Avery: Avery was wrongfully convicted in 1985 of sexual assault and attempted murder despite a time stamped and witnessed alibi. He served 18 years in prison before DNA evidence cleared him. In 2003, he was exonerated and released from prison.

Save

Share

Serial rapist Gregory Allen was found through DNA to be the real perpetrator. In a twist, Avery was again arrested in 2005 for the murder of a local photographer. He was convicted and sentenced to life in prison. He's the subject of Making of a Murderer.

Save

Share

Kirk Bloodsworth: Bloodsworth was convicted in 1985 of the rape and murder of a 9-year-old girl in Maryland. He was sentenced to death, but was exonerated in 1993 after DNA evidence cleared him. He was the first person in the U.S. to be exonerated based on DNA evidence.

Save

Share

Kimberly Shay Ruffner was later found to have been the real rapist and murderer. In a twist, both Bloodsworth and Ruffner had been serving time at the same prison (Ruffner for an unrelated charge). Their cells--wrongfully convicted and true perpetrator--were adjacent.

Save

Share

Brian Banks: In 2002, a 15 year old classmate accused 16 year old Brian Banks, a high school football star, of rape. The victim alleged it happened in the stairwell of their school during a summer session. He pled no contest at the advice of a lawyer and got five years in prison.

Save

Share

After his release, the alleged victim contacted him to speak. Banks secretly recorded the conversation wherein she admitted she lied. But she didn't want to recant for fear she'd have to return a $1.5M settlement from the school. Banks went on to play in the NFL.

Save

Share

While we're playing detectives on podcasts and online forums, it's important to remember that even the real detectives get it all wrong. "Innocent until proven guilty" should have a caveat "until possibly proven innocent again." Just look at the National Registry of Exonerations.

Save

Share

0

0 saves0 comments
Like
Comments
Share